I don't think anyone built the world to make us lonely.
What I think is that loneliness turned out to be a very profitable side effect, so nobody had a reason to fix it. Over time it got baked into the system.
No secret plan. Just an accident somebody found a way to bill for.
Facebook didn't launch to wreck social life. Google didn't set out to become a manipulative oracle, and Twitter didn't plan to polarize public debate. They started as tools with fairly decent ideals: connect people, organize knowledge, give everyone a voice. Then they found data, and data paid better than any ideal.
Our attention, our time and our moods could be turned into money with an efficiency no industry had seen before. From then on the goal stopped being 'connect people'. It became 'keep them here'.
The attention economy
This is what capitalism looks like now.
The product is habit, and the factory is your phone. Every scroll, notification and ad is a small, carefully tuned attempt to grab one more second of your life.
Nobody is conspiring. Profit has its own inertia and it pushes in one direction. Somewhere along the way companies learned that isolated people are docile, anxious people buy more and bored people click.
So, bit by bit, we swapped freedom for frenzy. Relationships became connections. Community became engagement.
Units of emotional consumption
We stopped being 'social beings' and turned into units of emotional consumption. Lonelier, more fragile, more impulsive.
Sad? Open Amazon. Bored? Watch a reel. Angry? Leave a comment.
Every emotion has a price tag, and every interaction feeds a machine that never sleeps. The funny part (not really funny) is that the machine is built by people who are stuck in it too.
The system is consistent
Big tech plays by the rules we all signed up for: infinite growth, every quarter better than the last, metrics up and to the right. And it follows them with impressive consistency.
If that drains our collective attention, burns out a generation's mental health or wrecks trust between colleagues and friends, too bad.
What matters is the curve going up. ๐
Meanwhile we, the ants, look around and can't tell who the enemy is anymore. There's no evil boss to point at, no ruling class. There's a system that turns everyone into a competitor, and empathy keeps dropping.
We work, we buy stuff, we scroll. At the end of the day we feel empty, and then guilty for feeling empty.
Connection as rebellion
Still, humans are social animals. We don't do well alone, and no amount of marketing will change that.
The system keeps selling loneliness as freedom. I think freedom sits closer to the opposite: talking to people, listening, saying hi to someone who doesn't say hi back, being kind to someone stuck in their own bubble.
Call it rebellion, if you like. In a world that makes money out of distance, every bit of real contact is a political act.
So what
I can't stop the system, and neither can you.
What we can do is make it a bit less efficient, one conversation at a time. Not much of a plan, but it's the one I've got.
Books to read
Tim Wu, The Attention Merchants
- How newspapers, radio, TV and then Big Tech turned attention into the thing being sold. Good background on why 'engagement' beat connection.
Shoshana Zuboff, The Age of Surveillance Capitalism
- How platforms turn our behavior and emotions into data, and data into predictions they can sell.
Zeynep Tufekci, Twitter and Tear Gas
- How social platforms help protests grow fast and then leave them fragile. A close look at the mechanics behind polarization.
James Bridle, New Dark Age
- Life inside opaque, metric-driven systems, and why more data doesn't bring more understanding.
Riccardo Luna, Qualcosa รจ andato storto
- An Italian take on how digital innovation went off track, and what policy could do about it.
